The Good Detective

I should tell you that once I picked up The Good Detective that it was so gripping and thrilling that I could not put it down until I finished it. I should tell you, but I can’t. The fact is that I started this book twice, two months apart, and each time I read the first chapter, got so incensed that I put the book down and didn’t finish it. But there was something about the blurb that kept pulling at me, reeling me back in; something that kept saying “read it, c’mon, you know you want to.” So, on the third try I vowed to get past the second chapter regardless of how angry I became. You know what happened, right? I didn’t put the book down until I completely finished the book! I stayed up all night long and finished reading it. I cannot believe how stupid I was to think I wouldn’t absolutely love this book – because I absolutely LOVED this book!!

51Bg7iOP81L._SX329_BO1,204,203,200_amazonThe Good Detective is P.T. Marsh, a “rising star” in a southern Georgia police department, at least he was until his wife and young son drowned in an accident that either was or might not have been a horrible accident. For over a year, P.T. has been a semi-functioning drunk. While in a bar, more like a strip club, he promises a dancer that he will have a talk with her abusive boyfriend. His “talk” actually means that PT beats the crap out of the guy after which he goes home to drink the remainder of his night away. Imagine his surprise when PT is called out the next morning to a murder scene and it is the boyfriend who is murder victim. This is the part that made me so angry. I have no tolerance for police brutality even when the person on the receiving end is a Neo-Nazi scumbag. However, all of this takes place on just a few pages at the very beginning of the book and the remainder of the book is incredibly fascinating! Read on…..

The death of the scumbag leads PT and his partner to the lynching site of a young African American boy. As they begin to search for the boy’s killer – since the best witness and/or suspect is now dead thanks to possibly PT- they begin to uncover something very sinister in their small rural, Georgia town, something that has been happening for centuries and it is dark and conspiratorial, and dangerous and of the very worst sort of nightmare that you can possibly imagine. I wouldn’t even attempt to perceive such atrocities except that I lived in the south and my father was from rural Georgia so I know that this horror does exist and that is what made this book so terrible and fascinating all at the same time. It was like watching a train derailing. I didn’t want to know, didn’t want to see the travesty that was unfolding but I couldn’t stop either.

McMahon has created characters on both sides of the fence that are perfectly conceptualized. They are not pretty, they are not good, they have flaws and some are so awful you won’t want them in your room, not even on your pages. I’m not sure you can create characters like this unless you have encountered them at some point in your lifetime. There were times that this read like something out of the 1930s or 40s, but then I remembered that there are parts of the rural south that still are very much like this. Who am kidding? There are places like this all over the US, not just the south. That’s what is so disturbing. This is happening everywhere, not just in small towns or in a particular region. In the end, there was a small amount of justice and a bit of redemption for PT as well. I can only hope that we will find this type of redemption for America soon. The quote below summed up the ending of book as well as my feelings for my history with the southern US:

There’s no place I’d rather travel than in the South…Even with our history, when I’m at Publix buying groceries, I see interracial couples. Lots of us. So as much as we struggle here with race, in some ways our struggle is closer to the surface and I hold out hope that this means it’s easier to fix. 

I know this was a bit of a rambling review. This was a very emotional book for me. The one thing I can say is that I highly recommend it and hope that you will read it, even it takes you a time or two to get started.

I owe much appreciation to #Edelweiss, @PutnamBooks, #JohnMcMahon and @PenguinPublishingGroup for my advanced copy of #TheGoodDetective

10 thoughts on “The Good Detective

    1. It was crazy good – after the first chapter. It dealt with topics I would prefer not to think about but the author did such an amazing job with it all. I was blown away – really! I still can’t believe how good it was. I’m ready for the next book!!

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Omg I agree the initial brutality would have put me off… But your review makes me nearly want to put this in my TBR… But it seems to be a darker read. I am finding my brain not liking this kind of gritty read. Brain rebels by giving me nightmares… Now you know why I read cozy and cakes 😍😂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This was darker than I prefer and it dealt with some issues that I’d rather not think about but, unfortunately racism is front and center in the US right now. Like it or not, it’s an issue that Americans are going to have to confront and hopefully sooner rather than later. This book is extremely realistic. But, now I’m reading a very happy, very lite chick lit to clear the darkness out of my mind. 🙂 It’s the only way I can survive.


      1. It is everywhere Mackey… I moved out of Facebook as I was called an idiot and other names due to my skin color. According to some, I was a terrorist… It was a harrowing experience to see friends asking me to prove I am not.. Luckily Facebook did not ask for a justification… There are horrible narrow minded people all over the world…

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I have my blog feed directly into a macsbooks account and the rest of my facebook account I’m shutting down. It’s becoming too horrible. The problem is that it’s too easy to say things when you’re looking at a person face to face. I may not agree with someone’s government – I don’t even agree with my OWN government – but everyone in that nation isn’t their government. There is just too much hate in the world right now and it’s being deliberately stirred up for a reason. 😦 I like books. They’re silent unless I want them to come alive. 😉


    1. Isn’t that the truth about the news. It’s really getting to be too much. This was a really tough read and, being from the southern US, it was especially difficult. But, it was incredibly well written and I’m glad I stuck it out.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s